top of page

The 2024 Homebuyer's Guide: Unpacking the Pros and Cons of HOA Living

Writer: Real Estate Investment ViewReal Estate Investment View

This post may contain affiliate links, meaning if you make a purchase via my links, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. For more information, please see my disclosure.

When diving into the real estate market, particularly as we enter 2024, understanding the Homeowners Associations (HOAs) can be pivotal for potential homebuyers. 


HOAs play a significant role in many residential communities, from condominiums and townhouses to single-family homes. This guide aims to illuminate the benefits and drawbacks of living within an HOA-governed community, assisting buyers in making well-informed decisions.


Key Takeaways:

  • Homeowners Associations (HOAs) play a crucial role in residential communities, enforcing rules and providing services to maintain common areas and amenities. 

  • HOA fees cover a range of services, from maintaining common areas and amenities to providing utilities, security, and insurance for shared spaces. 

  • The benefits of living in an HOA-governed community include access to well-maintained amenities, such as pools and fitness centers, and services like landscaping and trash removal. 

  • The drawbacks of HOA living can include significant fees and special assessments, restrictions on personal property use and modifications, and possible conflicts with HOA boards over community rules and management. 


What is an HOA?

A Homeowners Association (HOA) is an organization in a residential community that makes and enforces rules for the properties and its residents. Those who purchase property within an HOA's jurisdiction automatically become members and are required to pay association fees, used to maintain common areas and provide services.


10 Common HOA Fees and What They Cover

HOA fees, also known as homeowners association fees, are costs collected from HOA community residents governed by a Homeowners Association. These fees are used to cover various expenses associated with the maintenance and management of common areas and shared amenities within the community. The specific coverage of HOA fees can vary significantly from one association to another, but they generally include:


  1. Maintenance of Common Areas: This includes landscaping, upkeep of parks, playgrounds, walking paths, and any shared open spaces within the community.

  2. Amenity Upkeep: Many HOAs provide amenities like swimming pools, fitness centers, clubhouses, and sports courts. HOA fees fund the maintenance, repair, and operational costs of these facilities.

  3. Utilities for Common Areas: HOA fees often cover utilities for shared spaces, such as water, electricity, and gas for lighting and heating community areas and amenities.

  4. Trash Removal Services: Many communities include trash pickup and recycling services as part of the HOA fees, ensuring a clean and hygienic environment.

  5. Insurance: Part of the fees goes towards purchasing insurance for common areas and, in some cases, for the exteriors of buildings in the community. This insurance typically does not cover the interior of individual homes or personal property.

  6. Reserve Fund Contributions: HOAs are usually required to set aside a portion of the fees into a reserve fund. This fund is used for major repairs and replacements, such as fixing roofs, repaving roads, or updating amenities, ensuring the community remains in good condition.

  7. Property Management: If the HOA employs a property management company to oversee and manage community operations, fees may be used to pay for these services.

  8. Snow Removal and Landscaping: In communities with seasonal climates, HOA fees may cover the cost of snow removal during winter months and landscaping services to maintain the aesthetic appeal of common areas.

  9. Security: For gated communities or those with security, HOA fees fund the security services and equipment like gates, cameras, and patrols.

  10. Pest Control: Some associations include pest control services for common areas and, occasionally, individual units, to maintain a pest-free environment.


It's important for potential homeowners to review the HOA's governing documents and fee structure to understand exactly what the fees cover, as well as any additional costs that might arise.


Community Types Typically Governed By HOAs 

Communities typically governed by Homeowners Associations include:


  • Single-Family Home Developments: These are standalone houses in a neighborhood that shares common amenities and infrastructure, often governed by an HOA to maintain uniformity and community standards.

  • Townhouse Communities: Townhouses share walls with other units but usually have their own entrances and may have small yards. HOAs in these communities manage common areas and external property maintenance.

  • Condominium Complexes: In condo communities, residents own their individual units and share ownership of common areas. HOAs often handle exterior maintenance, landscaping, and amenities like pools and gyms.

  • Planned Communities: These are large-scale developments that include various types of housing (single-family homes, townhouses, condos) and amenities like parks, lakes, and sometimes schools.

  • Gated Communities: These are residential communities with restricted access, where an HOA typically manages security, roads, and common facilities.

  • 55+ and Retirement Communities: Designed for older adults, these communities offer age-restricted living with amenities and activities tailored to their residents.

  • Golf and Country Club Communities: These luxury communities are built around golf courses, country clubs, and often include extensive amenities like tennis courts, fitness centers, and dining facilities. An HOA will oversee the maintenance and membership rules of these communities.

  • Mixed-Use Developments: These developments combine residential units with commercial, retail, or office spaces, where an HOA may manage the residential aspects and common areas shared between the different uses.

  • Co-operative Housing (Co-ops): While not traditional HOAs, co-ops function similarly in that residents own shares in a corporation that owns the building, with a board making decisions about the property and its maintenance.


Each of these communities benefit from HOAs, offering a range of services from maintenance and amenities to enforcing community rules and regulations.


Pros of HOA Living

Community Amenities and Services

One of the most appealing aspects of HOA communities is the access to amenities such as swimming pools, fitness centers, and community parks that might be unattainable for an individual homeowner. Regular maintenance services ensure that community areas are well-kept, enhancing the overall living experience.


Examples:

  • Recreational Facilities: Many HOAs offer access to recreational amenities such as swimming pools, tennis courts, and playgrounds, providing convenient leisure activities within walking distance of home.

  • Fitness Centers: Some communities feature well-equipped fitness centers, saving residents the cost and time of traveling to a gym.

  • Landscaping Services: HOAs often take care of landscaping for common areas and sometimes even individual yards, ensuring the community maintains an attractive appearance without individual homeowners needing to manage it.


Property Value Maintenance

HOAs help maintain and even increase property values by ensuring a uniform and aesthetically pleasing environment. Strict community standards prevent neglect that could detract from the community's overall appeal.


Examples:

  • Aesthetic Standards: HOAs typically enforce architectural and landscaping guidelines, such as exterior paint colors and lawn maintenance. These guidelines help maintain a cohesive and attractive community appearance.

  • Community Upkeep: Regular maintenance of common areas and amenities, funded by HOA fees, helps ensure that the community remains in good condition, which can positively influence property values.

  • Controlled Development: By regulating modifications and additions to homes, HOAs help prevent changes that could negatively impact the community's character and property values.


Dispute Resolution and Community Engagement

HOAs offer structured methods to resolve disputes between neighbors, promoting a harmonious living environment. They also foster community engagement through organized events, creating a strong sense of belonging.


Examples:

  • Mediation Services: When conflicts arise between neighbors, many HOAs offer mediation services to help with resolution.

  • Community Events: HOAs often organize social events like holiday parties, movie nights, and block parties, providing opportunities for residents to connect.

  • Communication Channels: Through newsletters, websites, and community meetings, HOAs provide platforms for residents to stay informed and engaged with community affairs, ensuring a collective voice in decision-making processes.


Cons of HOA Living

Fees and Assessments

HOA fees can be a significant monthly expense, and unexpected assessments for major repairs or upgrades can be financially hard. Potential buyers should carefully review the HOA's fee structure and financial health.


Examples:

  • Monthly Dues: HOA fees are an additional monthly expense that homeowners must budget for, on top of their mortgage, taxes, and insurance.

  • Special Assessments: Homeowners may be hit with costs for unforeseen expenses or major projects, such as repairing community infrastructure, which can be a significant financial burden.

  • Increases Over Time: HOA fees can increase over time as the cost of services and maintenance rises, potentially straining homeowners' budgets.


Restrictions and Regulations

Living in an HOA community comes with a set of rules that can restrict personal freedoms, such as property modifications, pet ownership, and even paint colors. These restrictions can be too constraining for some homeowners.


Examples:

  • Exterior Modifications: Homeowners often face restrictions on exterior home renovations, such as paint colors, landscaping changes, and additions, limiting personal expression and property customization.

  • Pet Policies: HOAs may have rules regarding pets, including breed restrictions, size limits, and the number of pets allowed.

  • Rental Restrictions: Some HOAs limit or regulate the ability to rent out your home, including setting minimum lease terms and requiring tenant approval, which can affect your investment's flexibility and profitability.


Potential for Conflict

Disagreements with HOA boards over regulations or fees can lead to stressful conflicts. It's important for potential buyers to consider their willingness to comply with community rules.


Examples:

  • Disagreements with the Board: Homeowners may find themselves in disagreements with the HOA board over rules, fees, or the management of the community, leading to conflict.

  • Enforcement Inconsistencies: Perceived inconsistencies in rule enforcement can lead to feelings of unfair treatment among residents, fostering resentment.

  • Legal Disputes: In some cases, conflicts between homeowners and HOA boards can escalate to legal disputes, involving costly and time-consuming litigation.


Navigating HOA Documents

Before committing to an HOA property, review the association's bylaws, CC&Rs (Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions), and financial statements. Understanding these documents can provide insight into the community's governance and financial stability.


The HOA Document Hierarchy: What You Need to Know  

The hierarchy of HOA documents refers to the order of authority and precedence these documents have in the operations and management of an HOA community. Understanding this hierarchy is vital. Here's a breakdown of the typical hierarchy:


  1. State Laws and Statutes: At the top of the hierarchy are the state laws and statutes that govern HOAs in a particular state. These laws provide the legal framework within which all HOAs must operate and can include specific requirements for forming an HOA, rights and obligations of members, and guidelines for governance.

  2. Declaration of Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions (CC&Rs): The CC&Rs are the foundational governing documents for an HOA community. They include detailed information on the obligations of the homeowners and the HOA, restrictions on the use of property, architectural guidelines, and the rights and responsibilities of each party. The CC&Rs are recorded with the county recorder's office and are legally binding on all current and future homeowners within the community.

  3. Plat/Map: The plat or map is a detailed drawing that shows the layout of the community, including lot boundaries, common areas, streets, and easements. This document is crucial for understanding the physical and geographical features of the property.

  4. Articles of Incorporation: The Articles of Incorporation establish the HOA as a legal entity, typically a non-profit corporation. This document outlines the basic structure of the association, including its name, purpose, and the initial board of directors. The Articles of Incorporation are filed with the state and provide the HOA with certain legal protections and abilities.

  5. Bylaws: The Bylaws detail the internal governance structure of the HOA, including how the board of directors is elected, the frequency and conduct of board and membership meetings, voting rights, and the powers and duties of the board. Bylaws focus on the operation of the association rather than the use of the property.

  6. Rules and Regulations: These are the specific rules adopted by the HOA board to govern the behavior of residents and the use of common areas and amenities. Rules and regulations are more flexible and easier to amend than the CC&Rs and can cover a wide range of topics, from parking and pet policies to noise and the use of community facilities.

  7. Policies and Procedures: Often, HOAs will have additional policies and procedures that detail the rules and bylaws. These additional policies can include enforcement procedures, architectural review processes, and complaint resolution mechanisms. 


2024 Market Considerations

The current housing market trends, influenced by economic factors and buyer preferences, have a direct impact on HOA communities. Buyers should evaluate how these trends affect the long-term value and livability of HOA-governed properties.


HOA Impactful Market Trends Homebuyers Should Evaluate in 2024

  • Interest Rates: Keep an eye on current mortgage interest rates, as they directly impact your monthly payments and overall affordability of a home.

  • Economic Trends: Understand broader economic indicators such as inflation rates, employment figures, and GDP growth, as these can influence housing demand and prices.

  • Housing Supply and Demand: Analyze the balance between available housing inventory and buyer demand in your target area, which affects home prices and competition among buyers.

  • Location-Specific Factors: Consider local economic conditions, including job market health, infrastructure developments, and planned community projects, which can impact property values.

  • Technology and Remote Work Trends: With the increasing prevalence of remote work, evaluate how this trend affects desirable locations and home feature preferences, such as the need for home offices.

  • Sustainability and Energy Efficiency: Assess the importance of energy-efficient features and sustainable community practices, which are becoming significant factors for many homebuyers.

  • Market Cycles: Understand where the current market stands in terms of typical real estate cycles (growth, plateau, decline, recovery) to make a strategic buying decision.

  • Government Policies: Stay informed about any new government housing policies, tax changes, or incentive programs that could affect homebuyers.

  • HOA Stability and Fees: For properties within HOAs, evaluate the financial health and stability of the HOA, including current fees, reserve funds, and any planned assessments.

  • Long-Term Investment Potential: Consider the long-term appreciation potential of homes in various areas, factoring in upcoming community developments and changing demographics.


FAQs: Pros and Cons of HOAs in 2024

How can HOA fees impact my budget?

HOA fees are an additional monthly expense that can vary widely depending on the community's amenities and services. It's important to factor these fees into your budget as they can significantly impact overall affordability.


Are there any restrictions I should be aware of when buying in an HOA community?

Yes, HOAs often have rules regarding exterior property changes, pet ownership, parking, and even the color you can paint your house. It's essential to review the CC&Rs (Covenants, Conditions, and Restrictions) before purchasing.


What happens if I violate HOA rules in 2024?

 Violating HOA rules can result in fines, forced compliance, or in severe cases, legal action. It's important to understand and comply with your HOA's rules to avoid conflicts.


Can HOA fees increase, and if so, how often?

Yes, HOA fees can increase to cover rising costs of services, inflation, or funding for major repairs and improvements. Increases depend on the HOA's financial health and must be approved by the board.


Can I opt-out of an HOA after purchasing a home within its jurisdiction?

Generally, no. Joining the HOA is mandatory when you purchase a home in its jurisdiction, and you are bound by its rules and fees as long as you own the property.


Making the Decision

Deciding whether an HOA community is right for you involves weighing the enhanced lifestyle and property value maintenance against the fees, regulations, and potential for conflict. Use this guide as a checklist when considering your next home purchase within an HOA.


Conclusion 

In the 2024 real estate market, being well-informed about the pros and cons of HOA living is more important than ever. Engage with a real estate professional who can provide personalized advice and further insights into the specifics of HOA communities. Your dream home awaits, and understanding HOA living is a crucial step in making that dream a reality.

Comments


bottom of page