Flips That Still Hit: Cosmetic-Heavy, Starter-Home Targets (What Investors Say Is Working Right Now)

Real Estate Investment View
Sep 24
4 min read

This post may contain affiliate links, meaning if you make a purchase via my links, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. For more information, please see my disclosure.

Introduction: Why Cosmetic-Heavy Flips Still Work This Year

The headlines scream “Flipping profits are down!” and it’s true—gut rehabs and big renovations are riskier than ever. But here’s what investors on Reddit and BiggerPockets are whispering: cosmetic-heavy flips in starter-home markets are still working this year.

Why?

They’re faster.
They’re cheaper.
They’re the inventory first-time buyers are desperate for.

This post walks you through everything—criteria, risks, staging tricks, FHA flip rules, insurance headaches, and local research tips—so you don’t need to read 10 different forum threads.

What Counts as a “Cosmetic Flip”

Not every project is worth touching. Investors are drawing a clear line between cosmetic vs. structural work:

Cosmetic upgrades:

Interior & exterior paint
LVP flooring
Lighting fixtures
Kitchen cabinet refacing & updating hardware
New vanities and faucets in bathrooms
Landscaping and curb appeal

Not cosmetic (skip these unless margins are huge):

Foundation or roof replacement
Moving walls or plumbing
HVAC, sewer, or electrical overhauls

The consensus? Keep the rehab under $20K and finish in under 90 days. That’s the sweet spot investors say still pencils.

Why Starter Homes Are the Sweet Spot

Starter homes are moving faster than luxury flips right now. Here’s why:

Affordability: FHA/VA and low-down buyers dominate.
Move-in-ready bias: Buyers don’t want projects. They want clean, livable homes.
Resale security: Even in slower markets, starter homes have the deepest pool of buyers.

But don’t overdo it. One Redditor put it best: “I lost money turning a $220K starter into a $350K wannabe luxury home. Buyers just wanted clean floors and a fresh coat of paint.”

The Investor Playbook: Filters That Still Work

Before you swing a hammer, apply these filters:

Price band: Aim just below the local median (largest buyer pool).
Rehab cap: $20K or less in work.
Timeframe: 90 days or less from purchase to resale.
Exit margin: 10–15% of ARV or 60–80% annualized cash-on-cash return.

Pro tip: Investors call it “don’t fall in love with the deal.” If your exit math is fuzzy, pass.

Numbers That Matter: Holding Costs, Insurance & Appraisals

This is where many new investors trip up.

Insurance: Premiums are up across the country, and in some states (Florida, California, Louisiana), you may struggle to bind coverage at all. Factor in availability and delays—buyers may walk if their lender can’t get insurance cleared.
Holding costs: Hard money rates, utilities, taxes, and insurance add up. Run 30/60/90-day holding tables to stress test your deal.
Appraisals: FHA/VA loans may require second appraisals on flips sold within 180 days, often coming in low. Plan your timeline around it.

The FHA Flip Rule: Don’t Kill Your Own Deal

Most first-time buyers use FHA financing—so ignoring this rule can nuke your sale.

0–90 days after purchase: Ineligible for FHA. You can’t even contract with an FHA buyer.
91–180 days: Allowed, but a second appraisal is triggered.
181+ days: Clean.

Plan your exit timeline carefully. In FHA-heavy markets, don’t list until at least Day 91.

Scope Like a Pro: The Cosmetic Checklist

Here’s what investors are actually doing this year:

High-ROI cosmetic fixes:

Paint (interior/exterior)
LVP flooring throughout
Kitchen counters & cabinet paint/hardware
Bathroom vanities + mirrors
Modern light fixtures
Landscaping (mulch, plants, trim)

No-go signs that make investors walk:

Cracks in foundation
Outdated electrical panels or unsafe wiring
Active roof leaks
Sewer backups

Staging & Presentation: Where to Spend, Where to Save

According to NAR’s 2025 staging report, staged homes are selling faster and for higher prices. The most important rooms?

Living room
Primary bedroom
Kitchen

You don’t need to spend $5K. A few vignettes—modern couch, fresh bedding, bar stools—make photos pop. For investors, it’s about speed and ROI, not HGTV perfection.

Where Deals Are Still Coming From This Year

Forums highlight these lead sources:

Agent pocket listings (quiet flips from agents who know investors)
On-market price reductions (ugly houses that sat too long)
Tired landlords (mail lists + door knocking still work)
Builder close-outs (cosmetic issues or end-of-year sell-offs)
Live-in flips (first-timers buy, live, fix cosmetically, then sell)

How to Research Your Local Market Before You Buy

Even the best flipping formula fails if you ignore local realities. Investors constantly warn: what works in Dallas might flop in Denver.

Here’s a step-by-step checklist:

Insurance Availability & Costs

Call carriers and get quotes before closing.
Watch out for floodplains, wildfire zones, or older roofs.

Permitting Timelines

Ask your city/county: Do I need permits for cosmetic updates? What’s the turnaround?
Even small delays can kill your 90-day window.

Buyer Financing Mix

Check MLS comps: FHA-heavy areas mean you must respect the flip rule.
Conventional-heavy markets = faster exits.

Local Buyer Expectations

Tour open houses to see what “move-in ready” means in your area.
Match comps—don’t overspend on upgrades.

Hazard Maps

Use FEMA flood maps and wildfire maps.
Extra risk = slower closings, higher insurance.

Contractor Labor Market

If trades are booked 60+ days out, cosmetic flips lose their edge.
Build relationships with handyman crews who can move fast.

FAQs

What’s a safe profit margin this year?

Aim for at least 10–15% of ARV, but speed matters more than margin today.

Is flipping even worth starting now?

Yes—if you focus on cosmetic-heavy starter homes. Heavy rehabs are often losing money in this market.

How do I avoid over-improving a starter?

Scope only what comps justify. Match the neighborhood, not Pinterest.

Which upgrades return best?

Paint, flooring, curb appeal, and kitchen/bath light updates.

What kills deals late?

Insurance bind refusals, FHA flip rule timing, surprise sewer/HVAC issues, and low second appraisals.

Conclusion: Cosmetic Flips Still Hit—If You Play by the New Rules

Heavy rehabs may look glamorous on HGTV, but they’re hurting investor margins this year. The flips that still work? Starter homes with cosmetic upgrades.

If you filter deals ruthlessly, respect the FHA timeline, budget for insurance, and stage smart—you’ll still find spreads worth chasing!