Sell My Rental Property: A Practical How-To Guide from Realtor.com

This post may contain affiliate links, meaning if you make a purchase via my links, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. For more information, please see my disclosure.

Selling a rental property can often feel more complicated than selling your own home. Between tax rules, tenant agreements, and timing the market, many landlords find it challenging to know where to start. If you’re searching “sell my rental property” this year, you’re not alone—-thousands of rental property owners are deciding whether or not now is the best time to cash out. 

In this guide, inspired by Realtor.com’s expert advice, we’ll break down the process of selling your rental property into a practical and simple step-by-step guide. Whether you’re looking to reinvest via a 1031 exchange or are ready to move on from being a landlord, this how-to guide will help you make smarter and more informed decisions. 

Key Takeaways:

1. Know Your Numbers First: Before selling, carefully assess your equity, potential profits, and tax liabilities—including depreciation recapture and capital gains—to avoid surprises and plan the right strategy.

2. Tenants Impact the Sale: Whether your property is vacant or occupied can impact buyer type, pricing, and legal requirements, so it’s essential to handle tenant communication and local laws properly.

3. Timing and Preparation Matter: Market conditions, seasonal demand, and property readiness strongly influence how fast your rental sells and at what price, making preparation and timing essential.

4. Professional Guidance Reduces Risk: Working with tax professionals, real estate agents, and attorneys helps you navigate complex legal, financial, and market issues, ensuring a smoother and more profitable transaction.

Step 1: Assess Your Finances 

It’s essential to understand where your finances stand before listing your rental property for sale. Taking the time to run the numbers and accounting for taxes now will help you make informed decisions about strategy and timing.

• Check your equity: Subtract your mortgage balance from your property’s market value.

• Calculate potential profits: Factor in closing expenses, realtor commissions, and repair costs.

• Plan for taxes: Selling a rental property often triggers depreciation recapture and capital gains taxes. Work with a tax advisor to understand how much you’ll owe and whether you qualify for a 1031 exchange.

Pro Tip: Many rental property owners underestimate how much depreciation recapture impacts their bottom line. Don’t get caught unprepared—plan ahead.

Step 2: Understand the Tenant Factor 

If your rental has tenants, you’ll need to determine how their lease impacts the property sale. Make sure to check local tenant laws for notice requirements before making a decision. Mishandling this can lead to strained relationships or legal issues. 

1. Selling with tenants in place: Attracts investors who want instant rental income.

2. Asking tenants to vacate: Appeals to traditional homebuyers who want to move in.

Pros and Cons Snapshot:

• With tenants: Steady rental income during listing, but limits showings.

• Without tenants: Easier to stage and stage, but potential vacancy expenses.

Extra Tip: Some states have “tenant’s right of first refusal,” meaning renters must be given the option to purchase the property before you sell to someone else. Always verify your local regulations.

Step 3: Determine Your Timing (Why This Matters) 

Timing can impact how much you earn and how fast you close when selling a rental property. Interest rates, seasonal demand, and market conditions all influence buyer activity. Reviewing these fundamental factors will help you determine if now is the right time to sell.

1. Seasonal patterns: Spring and early summer often bring the strongest buyer interest.

2. Local trends: Monitor your city’s rental demand and sales prices.

If you’ve been unsure, this year may be the right time to sell before new tax policies or rental regulations take effect.

FAQ to Address: Is 2025 a good year to sell my rental property?

Yes, for many owners it is. Demand is steady, interest rates are leveling out, and new rental restrictions in some states are encouraging landlords to exit sooner rather than later.

Step 4: Prepare the Property for Sale

Preparing your rental property before listing it can help streamline the selling process. Investors and buyers often look for properties that are well-maintained and free of obvious concerns. Even small updates or repairs can help you avoid delays and support a stronger price. Deciding whether to make improvements or sell as-is depends on your goals and buyer expectations.

• Repairs: Fix obvious maintenance concerns that could raise red flags.

• Cosmetic updates: Clean landscaping, fresh paint, and decluttering go a long way.

• Staging vs. “as-is”: Decide if your buyer pool prefers a polished, move-in-ready look or a discounted, as-is investment opportunity.

Reminder: A little effort here can lead to stronger offers and shorter time on the market.

Pro Insight: Investors often care more about numbers than appearance. A clear maintenance history, rent roll, and profit-and-loss sheet may matter more than granite countertops.

Step 5: Explore Your Selling Options

There is more than one way to sell a rental property, and the right choice depends on your goals. Comparing these options will help you choose the best path forward.

• Conventional listing with a Realtor: Maximum exposure on MLS and Realtor.com.

• Sell to a cash buyer or an investor: Less hassle, faster closing, often at a discount.

• Use a 1031 exchange: Defer taxes by reinvesting into another investment property.

Extra Option: Some landlords also consider seller financing, where you act as the bank. This can attract buyers who don’t qualify for conventional loans and earn you interest income, though it carries risk.

Step 6: Work with Professionals

Selling a rental property involves financial, legal, and market complexities. Professionals can help you avoid expensive mistakes. Having a strong team in your corner can help protect your profits and boost peace of mind. 

1. Real estate agent: Provides marketing, pricing strategy, and negotiation.

2. Tax advisor/CPA: Helps you navigate capital gains and depreciation recapture.

3. Attorney: Ensures tenant laws and contracts are handled correctly.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Many landlords lose money or face delays by skipping key steps. 

Avoid these pitfalls:

• Overlooking taxes until closing day.

• Mismanaging tenant communication or notice requirements.

• Overpricing and letting the property sit on the market.

• Waiting too long in a declining market.

• Forgetting required documents (rent rolls, lease agreements, tax forms, maintenance records).

Checklist of Documents Buyers Often Ask For:

• Current lease agreements

• Tenant payment history

• Security deposit records

• Proof of recent repairs or upgrades

• HOA agreements (if applicable)

Conclusion

Selling a rental property this year doesn’t have to be complicated. By assessing your finances, timing the market, considering your tenants, and working with professionals, you’ll be positioned for a more straightforward and profitable sale.

If you’re ready, explore Realtor.com’s tools and resources to connect with a trusted local agent who understands the rental market in your area!