Good Tenants, Not Just High Rents: Under-Rated Rules for Profitable Apartment Investing

This post may contain affiliate links, meaning if you make a purchase via my links, I may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. For more information, please see my disclosure.

Every landlord learns this lesson eventually: high rent doesn’t always mean high profit.

On a Reddit thread about multifamily investing, one user shared how he pushed rent $200 above market to “maximize ROI.” Six months later, the tenant moved out, the unit sat vacant for 45 days, and he spent $2,800 on cleaning, repairs, and new marketing.

That “extra $200 per month” cost him over five grand in lost time and turnover costs.

The truth is simple but often ignored: profitability in apartment investing isn’t about charging the highest rent — it’s about keeping the right tenants.

In this guide, we’ll break down the under-rated rules that seasoned investors follow to ensure consistent, predictable returns — all backed by real data and forum wisdom.

The Myth of Maximum Rent

High rents look great on spreadsheets, but investors across BiggerPockets and r/realestateinvesting agree: the most expensive tenant is the one who leaves.

• Average cost of tenant turnover (repairs, cleaning, vacancy, advertising): $3,500–$5,000 per unit

• Average lost income per 30-day vacancy on a $1,500 unit: $1,500

• Typical rent increase that triggers turnover: 5–10% above market

That math alone kills ROI faster than most landlords realize.

Neil Patel often emphasizes the unseen cost of friction — and in real estate, friction = vacancy, conflict, and repair cycles. A long-term tenant paying slightly below market almost always outperforms a high-paying short-timer.

What Makes a “Good Tenant” (Hint: It’s Not Just a Credit Score)

Reddit’s most-upvoted landlord threads reveal a consistent pattern: investors who thrive focus less on income ratios and more on behavioral reliability.

The Real Traits of a Profitable Tenant

1. Pays rent on time — and communicates early if issues arise

2. Respects property — reduces long-term wear and repair costs

3. Stays long term — stabilizes income and boosts NOI (Net Operating Income)

4. Builds trust — less conflict, less oversight, more peace of mind

In a world of algorithms and background checks, these human traits matter most. As one Redditor put it: “I’d take a B-credit tenant who treats the unit like it’s theirs over an A+ who thinks they own the place.”

Screening for Stability (Not Just Qualification)

In 2025, tenant screening must be ethical, compliant, and comprehensive. Under U.S. law, landlords must follow the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and avoid discrimination under the Fair Housing Act (FHA) — which means being consistent, transparent, and objective.

Best-Practice Screening Checklist

• Verify income (2.5–3× rent minimum)

• Check credit reports for behavioral trends, not just score

• Call prior landlords for payment & property care

• Confirm stable employment or income source

• Meet applicants in person (or video) for rapport

• Document all communication to ensure fairness

Pro Tip: Experienced landlords report that character references often predict long-term reliability better than raw financials.

“You can fix a late rent. You can’t fix disrespect.” — Real estate investor comment, Reddit, 2024

Retention = ROI

Why Retention Matters More Than Rent

Many landlords focus on getting the highest possible rent, but experienced investors know that keeping good tenants makes more money over time. When you lose a tenant, you don’t just lose one month of rent — you lose thousands.

Between cleaning, painting, repairs, advertising, and vacancy time, turnover can easily cost you a full year’s worth of rent increases.

The Hidden Cost of Turnover

Imagine this: You raise rent by $150 a month to “maximize profit.” Your tenant leaves because the new rent feels unfair or maintenance requests went unanswered. Now you’re paying for a month or two of vacancy, cleaning, new carpets, and marketing. That $150 bump disappears — and you might even lose $3,000 to $5,000 in the process.

As one landlord wrote on Reddit: “I raised rent to market rate and lost my best tenant. It took two months to fill it and cost me more than I made.”

How Stable Tenants Create Real Profit

Now compare that to a landlord who values loyalty. They keep rent fair, fix things quickly, and treat their tenants like long-term customers instead of short-term profits. The tenant stays for years, paying on time and taking care of the place.

That consistency means:

1. No repainting or re-advertising

2. No vacancy gaps

3. Predictable monthly income

Even if the rent is $50–$100 less per month, the landlord often nets more at the end of the year because there’s no downtime, no turnover, and no stress.

Simple Ways to Keep Great Tenants

Retention doesn’t happen by accident — it’s earned. Small gestures and consistent service make the difference. 

Try these proven approaches from property managers and long-term investors:

• Respond quickly to maintenance requests (ideally within 24 hours).

• Reward good tenants with small upgrades like ceiling fans, new paint, or smart thermostats.

• Renew early — reach out 60–90 days before the lease ends to lock in another year.

• Communicate clearly — a friendly message or thank-you note after renewals goes a long way.

• Be fair with rent increases — small, predictable raises (2–3%) beat big jumps that drive people away.

Property Management Habits That Build Trust

Habits of High-Trust Landlords

1. Clear communication (email + text follow-ups)

2. Transparent policies (no hidden fees or inconsistent enforcement)

3. Consistent documentation (lease renewals, inspections, receipts)

4. Prompt maintenance (tenant satisfaction = lower vacancy risk)

In short, trust = retention = profit.

Legal and Compliance Edge

Quick Legal Reference Points

• Always provide written leases — verbal agreements erode trust and legal protection.

• Review local rent control or eviction laws before adjusting terms.

• Handle deposits per state escrow requirements.

• Use standardized screening criteria and apply equally to all applicants.

Authoritative Reference: HUD Fair Housing Overview

Beyond Tenants — Full Profit Picture

If you master good-tenant principles, you’ve solved 70% of apartment-investment profitability. 

But for true mastery, explore:

1. Local market analysis

2. Maintenance budgeting & capex forecasting

3. Financing strategies

4. Scaling from duplex to multifamily portfolios

5. Exit planning (refi, sale, 1031 exchange)

Each of these complements your tenant strategy and ensures sustainable returns.

Conclusion

Good tenants are the silent engine of every profitable apartment investment. They protect your assets, your cash flow, and your sanity. While many investors chase rent premiums, the pros quietly build long-term wealth on trust, service, and relationships.

“You don’t make money when you raise rent. You make money when your tenants stay.” — Experienced landlord, r/realestateinvesting